Original Research Article
Year: 2016 | Month: July-September | Volume: 1 | Issue: 3 | Pages: 20-28
Determination of Cloud and Pour Point of Crude Oil with Reference to Crude Transportation
Emmanuel, O. Eyankware1, Wisdom, C. Ulakpa2, Moses O. Eyankware3
1Department of Gas Engineering, Faculty of Engineering, University of Port-Harcourt, P. M. B 5323, Rivers State, Nigeria.
2Department of Chemical Engineering, Faculty of Engineering, Odumegwu Ojukwu University, Anambra State, Nigeria.
3Department of Geology, Ebonyi State University, Abakaliki,. P.M.B. 053. Ebonyi State.
Corresponding Author: Emmanuel, O. Eyankware
ABSTRACT
In this study, the cloud and pour point of the Nigerian Niger Delta Crude oil were determined so as to ascertain the temperature at which wax crystallizes and precipitates during crude transportation. Four (4) crude samples were collected and analysed in the laboratory and the results showed that each of the samples had varying cloud points; Sample A - 230C, Sample B - 140C, Sample C - 230C and Sample D - 200C with a mean value of 200C. Same trend was also exhibited by the pour points; Sample A - 110C, Sample B - 20C, Sample C - 140C and Sample D - 80C with a mean value of 8.750C. It was then concluded that wax deposition during crude transportation in the region can be prevented especially in onshore pipelines if efficient preventive measures are put in place being that the region in the tropics with a minimum ambient temperature of 180C. Factors that affect cloud and pour point of crude oil were also highlighted and recommendations that will help prevent crude oil from wax crystallization and precipitations were given.
Keywords: Cloud Point, Pour Point, Crude oil, Wax Deposition, Paraffin Wax.
INTRODUCTION
Crude oil is a naturally occurring mixture, consisting predominantly of hydrocarbons, sulphur, nitrogen and metals (Yasin, et al., 2013). Crude oils are complex but mainly paraffinic, napthenic and aromatic (Wang et al., 1994). Crude oils contain all normal alkenes from C1 to C120 (Khanorkar et al., 1996). However, this percentage rises to 35% in highly paraffinic and decreases to zero in highly biograded oils (Ali, et al., 1989). Ajienka and Ikoku, (1997) stated that Nigeria has a substantial reserve of paraffinic crude oils known for their good quality (low sulphur, high API gravity), and containing moderate to high contents of paraffinic waxes. Waxy crude oils have undesirably high pour points and are difficult to handle where the flowing and ambient temperatures are about or less than the pour-point and according to Peng et al., (2014) high pour point oil reservoirs are usually part of the developed oilfields in various regions worldwide. Elijah et al., (2012) also stated that waxy crude oils exhibit Bingham non-Newtonian flow behaviour below the cloud point due to wax crystallization. The Nigerian Niger Delta crude oil, which is the mainstay of Nigerian economy, exhibits waxiness, with deposits in the range of 30-45 % (Adewusi, 1997; Fasesan and Adewumi, 2003; Taiwo et al., 2009 and Oladiipo et al., 2009). During its transportation, because oil temperature at initial station is higher than the ambient temperature, the oil temperature continues to decrease, and when it decreases to the wax precipitation point of crude oil, wax crystal in crude oil starts to precipitate, grow, and deposit on the pipe wall finally; sediments on pipeline will reduce the effective flow area of the pipeline, increase friction, and thus reduce transmission capacity of the pipeline (Tian et al., 2014). Also, production tubing had waxed up in several cases and this had resulted in the expensive maintenance procedure of wax cutting which involves using scrapers conveyed by wireline. Billions of dollars has been lost to its prevention and remediation (Oladiipo et. al., 2009). Wax deposition in crude oils has been a problem in crude transportation for a long time and according to Al-Besharah et al., (1987) the difficulties in pipeline transportation are due to this complex nature of crude oil, which cause a variety of difficulties during the production, separation, transportation and refining of oil.
When a waxy crude oil is cooled, the heavier paraffinic constituents begin to separate as solid crystals once the solubility limit is exceeded (Karan, et al., 2000). Elijah et al., (2012) stated that thermodynamically, the solid-liquid phase boundary temperature, that is the maximum temperature at which the solid and liquid phases co-exist in equilibrium at a fixed pressure, is the wax appearance temperature (WAT). It is also known as the Cloud Point which according to (Holder and Winkler, 1965; Hussain et al., 1999) depends on wax concentration, the crystallization habit of wax, and the shear stability of different wax structures. Crude oil starts to lose its flow characteristics when wax crystallization begins to occur. The lowest temperature at which the oil is mobile is termed Pour Point and these two temperature points are of immerse importance in crude transportation.
The aim of this research is to determine the cloud and point of Nigerian Niger Delta crude oil as to how it affects crude transportation. The specific objectives are listed below;
To determine the temperature at which the sampled crude oil becomes semi solid and loses their flow characteristics.
i)
To compare the cloud and pour point of the different crude samples.
ii)
To investigate the various factors that can affect the cloud and pour point of crude oils.
iii)
To make recommendations as to how wax deposition can be prevented during crude transportation.
LITERATURE REVIEW
Due to flow assurance problems encountered during crude transportation using pipelines in the oil and gas industry, it has become of paramount importance to study the different factors that enhance wax deposition in pipelines. Several researchers have done work on the subject matter and have been able to predict using scientific methods conditions that promote wax deposition while also professing ways to combat its undesirable occurrence. These researchers include; Hunt, (1962); Matlach et al., (1983); Agrawal et al., (1990); Bern et al., (1980); Burger and Perkins, (1981); Brown, Niesen and Erickson, (1993); Svendsen, (1993); Nazar et al, (2001); Mehrotra and Bhat, (2007); Zhang and Liu, (2010); Ramirez Jaramillo et al., (2004); Ribeiro et al., (1997); Lee, (2008). Amongst the numerous researches done, some are discussed here.
Elijah et al., (2012) stated that the main components of the heavy fraction of hydrocarbon which participate in the solid phase formation include asphaltenes, diamondoids, petroleum resins and wax. Petroleum wax consist mainly saturated paraffin hydrocarbons with number of carbon atoms in the range of 18-36. Wax may also contain small amounts of naphthenic hydrocarbons with their number of carbon atoms in the range of 30-60. Wax usually exists in intermediate crudes, heavy oils, tar sands and oil shales. There are three main factors that affect wax deposition in flow systems which according to Bott and Gudmundsson (1977) are flow rate, temperature deferential, and cooling rate, as well as surface properties.
Zhen et al. (2014) proposed that early studies suggested that, the mechanism of wax deposition could be summarized as the following four types: molecular diffusion, shear dispersion, Brownian diffusion and gravity settling, in which molecular diffusion was generally considered as the most important mechanism causing wax deposition. Singh et al., (2000) confirmed that shear dispersion, Brownian diffusion and gravity settling had little influence on wax deposition, namely molecular diffusion was dominant mechanism of wax deposition. Hamouda and Davidsen (1995) also considered that shear dispersion had an influence on wax deposition, but the main cause was still molecular diffusion, and he ignored the influence of shear dispersion when establishing the prediction model of wax deposition.
Singh et al., (2000) proposed that the process of wax deposition could be described by the following steps: (1). Gelation of the waxy oil on the cold surface, (2). Diffusion of waxes towards the gel layer from the bulk, (3). Internal diffusion of these molecules through the trapped oil, (4). Precipitation of these molecules in the deposit, (5). Counter diffusion of de-waxed oil out of the gel layer. This proposition was confirmed by measuring the carbon number distribution in the sample of wax deposition layer under different experimental time.
MATERIALS AND METHODS
Four (4) crude samples were obtained from the Niger Delta region in Nigeria and analyzed to determine parameters such as cloud and pour points, pH, density and specific gravity.
The apparatus used to determine the pH of the samples are Hanna pH meter and beaker. The samples are poured into four beakers and the Hanna pH meter was used to measure their respective pH levels.
Hanna pH meter is as shown in Fig. 1.
Figure 1: Hanna pH meter determining the pH of a crude sample
Specific Gravity Determination:
Apparatus used in specific gravity determination were hydrometer and 200ml volumetric cylinder. The cylinder was filled to the mark with the respective crude samples and the hydrometer was inserted into the medium to determine their specific gravity as shown in Fig. 2. Reading was taken from the lower meniscus.
Figure 2: Specific gravity of a crude sample being determined with a hydrometer
Figure 3: Water Bath and Heater
Density Determination:
Cloud Point Determination:
Apparatus used in cloud point determination were test jar, cork carrying thermometer, water bath with heater, cloud point chamber and crushed ice. Experimental procedures are as enumerated below;
a)
Test jar was filled to the level mark, closed tightly by the cork carrying the thermometer and placed into a bath of crushed ice as shown in Fig. 3.
b)
Test jar was removed from the jacket quickly without disturbing the specimen. Inspection for cloud point was done and jacket replaced. Operation was done without exceeding time duration of three (3) seconds.
c)
Since cloud point is the temperature of a liquid specimen when the smallest observable cluster of hydrocarbon crystals first occurs upon cooling under prescribed conditions, observation was done and cloud point was reported to the nearest 1˚C. At this point, cloud is observed at the bottom of the test jar, which is confirmed by continued cooling.
Pour Point Determination:
Same apparatus that were used in cloud point determination were used in pour point determination. Experimental procedures are enumerated below;
A sample of worm crude was filled to the level mark. The test jar was tightly closed by the cork carrying the test thermometer and placed in a bath of crushed ice.
a)
The test jar was inspected at an interval of at three (3) minutes by holding in a horizontal position for a few seconds before returning it to cool.
b)
The pour point was reached when the oil surface stayed in the vertical position for a period of 5 seconds without sagging. At this point the thermometer was inserted to cool for 10 seconds and the temperature of the oil was taken.
c)
The pour point was 3˚C higher than the thermometer reading. Crude sample at pour point is shown in Fig. 4. Also, Fig. 5 shows cloud and pour point chambers.
Figure 4: Crude Sample at Pour Point
Figure 5: Clouds and Pour Points Chamber with Test jars inserted
RESULTS AND DISCUSSIONS Table 1: Results showing pH, Density, Specific Gravity, Cloud and Pour Point of Crude Samples.
Unit Sample A Sample B Sample C Sample D Mean pH - 5.2 5.7 5.2 5.8 5.5 Density kg/m3 850 790 830 900 842.50 Specific Gravity - 0.85 0.79 0.83 0.90 0.84 Pour Point (0C) 11 2 14 8 8.75 Cloud Point (0C) 23 14 23 20 20 From Table 1, it can be noticed that the cloud points of crude samples A, C and D have temperature limit that is higher than the least expected annual mean temperature (>180C) being that Nigeria has a tropical climate with the exception of sample B which implies that wax deposition can be easily prevented in the region. Also from the table, it is evident that the pour points of the samples are below ambient temperature especially for onshore pipeline facilities in the Niger Delta region. A critical look at Table 1 shows that sample C has the highest pour point while sample B has the lowest pour point signifying that sample C has the highest paraffin content while sample B has the lowest paraffin content.
Fig. 6 shows that a linear relationship exists between specific gravity and cloud point of the crude samples. It is also shown in Fig. 7 that a linear relationship exists between specific gravity and pour point of the crude samples. This linear trend for crude oils is reported by Modesty (Kelechukwu, 2011).
Figure 6. Graph showing relationship between Specific Gravity and Cloud Point
Figure 7. Graph showing relationship between Specific Gravity and Pour Point
Based on the findings, it is imperative to say that the Nigerian Niger Delta crude oil is the type of crude oil that has a low tendency towards forming wax crystals especially in onshore pipeline facilities as far as the minimum flow temperature is kept above the cloud point which is at a mean value of 200C for the crude samples. In order words, costly extreme wax deposition management measures can be avoided if crude temperature can be maintained at a temperature higher than the average cloud point. Factors Affecting Cloud and Pour Points of Crude Oil
There are certain factors that directly affect the cloud and our point of crude oil. Proper management of these parameters will help control the rate with which crude oil reaches its cloud and pour point. These parameters are discussed as follows;
a)
Temperature Differential: Wax deposit decreases with an increase in temperature difference (Kelechukwu et al., 2010). This proposition is in total agreement with previous studies carried out by Cole and Jossen (1960); Haq (1978) and Tang et al., (2002), but however, disagreed experimentally that wax deposition would increase by increasing temperature difference between cold pipe wall temperature and feed temperature as reported by Nazar et al., (2001), and Jennings and Weispfennig (2005). This drop in wax deposition rate with increase in temperature difference could be attributed to the extra heat gained or added in the solution, which would further move the solution away from its cloud point. Hence the process of crystal formation and their deposition is a function of temperature difference (Norman, 1989). Since wax deposition is directly affected by cloud and pour point, there exists a direct relationship between these temperature points and temperature differential between the waxy crude and pipeline wall.
b)
Paraffin Wax Content: The amount of paraffin wax in a crude oil sample affects its cloud and pour point temperatures. Wax deposition has a higher tendency to occur in crude oils with high paraffin wax content than those with lesser paraffin wax because wax can easily agglomerate when it is high in content than when it is not. As such, the amounts of paraffin wax present in a crude sample directly affect the rate at which it will reach its cloud and pour point.
c)
Flow rate: Mohammed (2007) hypothesized that a higher flow shear, which is a function of flow rate, leads to lesser but likely harder wax deposit build up. Thus wax deposition gradually decreases with increase in flow rate and turbulence. The effect of increasing flow rate, decreasing the amount of wax deposited or entrapped oil in the deposited, was also reported in two subsequent coaxial shear cell studies by Lee-Tuffnell (1996) and Dawson (1996). This can be explained; that as the velocity of the moving stream increases, the molecules gain more energy with a corresponding increase in temperature which would reduce the tendency with which the waxy crude would reach its cloud and pour point.
d)
Surface Properties: Properties such as density, specific gravity and viscosity are determinants of the cloud and pour point of crude oil sample. There exists a relationship between density and specific gravity as shown in Table 1. Also, viscosity is affected by specific gravity because the denser a fluid, the more viscous it becomes. Since viscosity directly affects cloud and pour point, it is essential to state that the higher the density, specific gravity and viscosity of crude oil sample, the more its tendency towards reaching its cloud and pour point as shown in Fig. 6 and Fig. 7 respectively.
CONCLUSION AND RECOMMENDATIONS In oil and gas industry, wax deposition has been an age long problem and its determination and control has been a very important topic for researchers. A pertinent factor of wax deposition is the cloud and pour point at which crude oil forms wax crystals and loses its flow characteristics which has been the focus of this research. As highlighted by the researcher, there are certain factors that influence cloud and pour point temperature which if properly managed will help curb the occurrence of wax crystallization and deposition. So, these factors should be effectively and efficiently managed by midstream companies involved in the transportation of crude oil in a bid to prevent deposition of wax.
The Nigerian Niger Delta crude oil as shown in this research is one that can be easily managed especially onshore at conditions that will help prevent wax deposition. Following this, preventive measures such as installation of heaters along flow lines to help keep crude temperature above the cloud point of the fluid should be carried out. Also, the use of chemical solvents like wax inhibitors and Pour Point Depressants (PPD’s) should be encouraged. (Bagdat and Masoud, 2015) also proposed that Ethylene Tetra-Fluoro Ethylene (ETFE) internal plastic pipe coating is the most appropriate solution for paraffin deposition in the pipelines. As such its usage can be encouraged over rigid PVC pipes and steel pipes which are commonly used in the oil and gas industry for crude transportation.
REFERENCES
·
Cole, R.J., Jessen, F.W., (1960). Paraffin Deposition. Oil Gas J., 58: 38-87.
·
Dawson R.V., (1996). 3 SCR 783 - Supreme Court of Canada - Docket Number: 24883.
·
Haq, M.A., (1978). Deposition of paraffin wax from its solution with hydrocarbons.
·
Hunt, E.B.Jr., (1962). Laboratory Study of Paraffin Deposition, Journal of Petroleum Technology, 14,
·
Mohammed, Z., (2007). Industrial & Engineering Chemistry Research, ACI., 46: 14.
·
Norman FC (1989). Paraffin Deposition in Petroleum Production.
How to cite this article: Eyankware EO, Ulakpa WC, Eyankware MO. Determination of cloud and pour point of crude oil with reference to crude transportation. International Journal of Science & Healthcare Research. 2016; 1(3): 20-28.
**************
ρ crude oil = Specific Gravity * ρ water
Where ρ crude oil = Density of crude oil sample
ρ water = Density of water = 1000 kg/m3
Parameter